If you’ve inherited a box of old coins or stumbled upon rare paper money, you may be holding on to a hidden fortune. But where should you sell them for the best value, safely and efficiently? We break down five of the most trusted places to sell rare coins and paper currency based on expert recommendations and current market trends.
1. Heritage Auctions: The Industry Giant
Heritage Auctions is one of the world’s largest collectibles auction houses, specializing in numismatic items. With a strong reputation for auctioning rare U.S. coins and currency, Heritage is a go-to for serious collectors and sellers.
- Offers free appraisals and cataloging for premium items.
- Known for record-breaking sales in rare currency.
- Suitable for high-value collections seeking international exposure.
Heritage conducts both live and online auctions, making it accessible while providing expert guidance throughout the selling process.
2. eBay: Reach Millions of Buyers Worldwide
The eBay marketplace allows sellers to list and sell rare coins and bills directly to buyers. With millions of active users, eBay provides massive visibility—but with it comes responsibility.
- Sellers manage their listings, shipping, and customer service.
- eBay charges listing and final value fees.
- Ideal for common-to-mid-range valuable coins and currency.
Make sure your listings are detailed, include clear photos, and are competitively priced. Always check buyer reviews and ratings before finalizing sales.
3. Stack’s Bowers Galleries: Auction Expertise
Stack’s Bowers Galleries is another leading auction house in numismatics. They are known for auctioning high-profile collections and offering personalized service.
- Offers free evaluations for coin and currency submissions.
- Runs both live and digital auctions.
- Trusted by top collectors and institutions globally.
With a long-standing reputation dating back to the 1930s, Stack’s Bowers ensures professional handling of rare and valuable collections.
4. APMEX (American Precious Metals Exchange): Easy, Fast Transactions
APMEX is one of the largest online buyers of precious metals, coins, and rare currency. If you want a quick sale with reliable payout, this is a strong contender.
- Offers online quotes for items submitted.
- Shipping and insurance are coordinated for sellers.
- Payment is usually processed within 1-3 business days of appraisal.
While better known for bullion and metals, APMEX also accepts numismatic coins and select banknotes, provided they meet condition and rarity standards.
5. Local Coin Dealers: Personalized and Instant
Sometimes, the best place is just around the corner. Reputable local coin shops or dealers can provide face-to-face appraisals and instant cash offers. Search for certified dealers using tools from:
Benefits of going local include:
- Immediate appraisals and cash offers.
- Opportunities to build a relationship for future transactions.
- Less risk of shipping loss or delays.
However, it’s wise to get multiple opinions and verify the dealer’s credentials through official associations.
Tips Before You Sell
Regardless of where you choose to sell your currency, keep these key points in mind:
Authenticate and Appraise
Get your coins and bills evaluated by professional graders like PCGS or NGC for coins, and PMG for paper money. Certification adds trust and can significantly increase the item’s value.
Research the Platform
Know the terms, fees, and audience of the platform you’re using. For example, while eBay provides visibility, auction houses might help you secure higher bids for premium items.
Watch Out for Scams
Unfortunately, rare coins attract fraudulent buyers. Always use platforms with secure payment systems and established reputations.
Know What You Have
A simple online guide like the U.S. Mint Coin Guide or GovInfo Currency Resources can help identify whether your coins and bills are common or collectible.
Final Thoughts
Selling rare coins and paper money doesn’t have to be intimidating. Whether you choose an online auction giant like Heritage or a local expert from the PNG network, the key is knowing what your items are worth and choosing the platform that fits your needs best. With preparation and due diligence, your collectibles could fetch a price that surprises you—in a good way.
This article has been carefully fact-checked by our editorial team to ensure accuracy and eliminate any misleading information. We are committed to maintaining the highest standards of integrity in our content.
Himanshu Sharma writes for Weekend Spy, focusing on recruitment, government schemes, and current affairs. He is dedicated to making complex information accessible to readers.
Himanshu enjoys playing chess, hiking, and trying new recipes, always seeking ways to combine his love for writing with his passion for exploration. Connect with Drop him an email at [email protected].
